TURKISH COMMANDERS' MEMORIAL
KOMUTANLARI
ANITI
IF STONES COULD SPEAK
ALONG THE DARDANELLES (EUROPE)
back to if stones could speak
What often tipped the
scales in favour of the Turks and reinforced the technical stalemate, was
better military leadership. Whether in the shape of German commanders like
Liman von Sanders, Carl Mühlmann, Major Willmer, Hans Kannengieser, or Turkish
staff and commanders like Kazim Bey, Esat Pasha, Halil Bey and Mustafa Kemal,
the Germans and Turks possessed better higher commanders than the Allies. It
was this final factor which overcame Allied Naval advantages, and tended to
solidify the technical stalemate at Gallipoli. Yet it was this very technology
that produced the stress of modern war …
"Gallipoli 1915", (Stroud
2002), Tim
Travers, p. 176
line ran up and down in all directions, yelling like
Jews in a synagogue; the officers also failed in this regards. Divisional
and regimental commanders were nowhere to be seen.
Carl Mühlmann quoted in "Gallipoli 1915", (Stroud 2002), Tim
Travers, p. 176
It is incredible what levels of talent the senior Turkish officers can attain when it comes to disap-pearing. The scenes that we witnessed were not encouraging. Instead of advancing silently in previously agreed-upon directions, the skirmish
When troops
fale, it is probably due to their leaders ... In the fight I often had the
impression: the unit is a willing mass, but they are lacking leaders to give
them purpose. Out of this willingness and absolute acceptance of the
authority of the superior follows the extraordinarily great influence a leader
can have on his inferiors, if he is good, energetic and purposeful and Turkish
– but he must be Turkish ...
Translated from
“Gallipoli - Significance and course of the campaign”, (Berlin 1927), Colonel Hans
Kannengieser, p.140
last updated : 17/11/06
This website has been prepared by
the first authentic hotel on the Gallipoli peninsula
